HomeschoolingResourceCenter.org                                                                                                              Home    |  Search    |  About Us    |  Contact Us
Popular Feature Articles
Getting Started in Homeschooling
How to Homeschool Topics
Community Help and Activities
Resources for the Homeschooler
Audio and Video Presentations
News Item
URGENT UPDATE - IMPORTANT ISSUE

August 2011
Look Before You Leap

Riddle: When is homeschooling not homeschooling? The answer may not be as obvious as you think. With homeschooling gaining popularity, the public school systems and other alternative education outlets are taking note of lost revenues and looking for ways to latch onto the homeschooling market.

One such attempt in Michigan is luring homeschoolers with marketing promises of free computers, Internet capabilities, and unfounded promises of access to high school sports. And other states are following suit. How does this impact families who have taken on the responsibility of educating and training their children at home? More than you think. The issues raised could change the face of homeschooling.

To help the homeschooling community evaluate this and similar alternatives, we asked permission to reprint a letter written by a veteran homeschooler of over 12 years who founded one of the first homeschooling support groups in Southeast Michigan and still serves as one of its leaders. Debbie Rossi also conducts workshops on Getting Started and Homeschooling through High School, as well as consulting with and mentoring young mothers and families. She and her husband, Paul, direct the homeschooling sports program in the area as well. The original letter was in response to an email written by a concerned homeschooling mother.

An Open Letter to Homeschoolers From a Veteran
by Debbie Rossi

Yes, we have been following this new development and a couple similar situations around the state. I hope you have a few minutes for me to share my thoughts.

The fact that you are questioning this is a very good thing. This is giving you the opportunity to re-evaluate WHY you chose to “homeschool” in the first place. Those reasons are your “vision” and are absolutely necessary in order to make wise choices for your family. In order to determine if this is right for your family or not, it is really imperative that you understand WHY you brought your children home to teach them in the first place.

Personally, I believe that because we have called it “home school” we left ourselves open to the emotional tactics used in marketing, and we started focusing more on the “school” part rather than the “home” and family part. I think the plethora of curriculum over the past 10 years or so supports this fact. The basics that children need for a solid foundation for life-long learning have not changed – just the delivery methods have changed and been marketed big-time to schools, the homeschool community, and even the church.

Because raising our children is so intensely emotional for us, most of us have lost sight of WHY we brought our children home from school (or never sent them) because we have been impacted by wanting the “BEST” for our children. We have neglected to renew our minds to what the Lord was really calling us to do – His BEST. We were pretty clear in the beginning because there weren’t many choices and we all stayed pretty tight in supporting one another with prayer, encouragement, and sharing what we were learning and what the Lord was teaching us.

But over the years we have all been tossed to and fro with doubt when we saw all the “good” stuff and “best” stuff advertised at conferences, in magazines, and online. If it is one thing that Moms are good at it is the dangerous Game of Doubt. (And this is how big money is made in the marketplace!)

In order to determine if your homeschool freedoms are at risk, you need to understand what your freedoms are---what do you appreciate about having your children home with you? Yes, it is very hard, time-consuming, sacrificial work---but what have been the benefits and blessings of that choice for your family? What is your definition of “freedom?” What is your definition of “free?” (This would be a very good lesson for our children to learn and understand, too.)

Regarding the new online options, here are our thoughts---and they are shared by many families teaching their children at home, especially veterans:

  • Through "school of choice," (quote from message you sent) This is public school at home. So in the literal sense of the words, it is school at home – “home schooling.”
  • In order to receive all the FREE stuff, you will need to enroll in the public school system. The online application for virtual academies is pretty lengthy.
  • Anyone who pays attention to the government and how it has come to work, knows that ALL children receiving any kind of services that are funded by the public sector will be tracked. The computers are programmed for that and required by the Federal Government to do so if they are receiving money from the Federal Government. Do you know of ANY public schools that don’t receive money from the feds? Questions to ask: Who is paying for the internet connection? If the school system is, how is that governed?
  • Because this is public school, the materials will all be public school approved – meaning there will be no mention of God because of their view of Separation of Church and State.
  • Another aspect of the government is exactly one of your concerns: Who knows what restrictions lie ahead? They won’t look like restrictions when they are presented; they will look like enhancements. Again, anyone watching the political landscape over the past few years especially can know that the government is very savvy when trying to convince the people of their programs and ideas. (One issue that comes to mind immediately is how will the school system be sure that parents are at home monitoring their children’s school work? Or is the parents’ presence not an issue?)
  • How much time do you really want your child sitting in front of a computer screen each day? If sitting in a chair at a desk in a classroom is restrictive, how much more restrictive is this? Don’t get me wrong---I understand that learning to use the computer is a very important skill for our children, but as parents, do you want the freedom to control that amount of time? If the curriculum is online, this will be very difficult for parents to control.
  • The topic of “sports” is a whole other discussion. I won’t elaborate, but just because a child wants to play on a public school team, does not mean they will be able to do so. There is a lot involved in playing sports, especially at the public school level. [And very few programs are free.]
  • One of the things that I find funny in all this is the issue of “socialization.” Gee, that was the number one fear-mongering tool used against us the first several years that we had our children home with us. At the very least, as families we were “socializing” face-to-face” and in the “real” world every day. Although I see the benefit of online social networking and some online learning, spending a majority of the day with a computer does not equate to healthy socialization to me.
I could go on, but I think you have a good idea of where we stand on this issue. I think that if you are looking for online resources for learning, there are many options that will support the foundation that Christian families are building on. Of course, they will not be FREE – there will be a monetary cost involved. As parents, we need to evaluate the real cost of the FREE programs being offered to us because everything comes at a price.

I am sure that the online academy options will be a viable option for many families, especially those who simply want their children out of the school building and out of the school culture. It is very important for parents to do their own due diligence and research any virtual academy they are considering and the resources the academies are incorporating into their system. In Michigan, many are using e2020, Aventa, and Plato. I would also research K12 because they were the first to bring this public option into the state of Michigan last year. Parents need to ask lots of questions.

Again, this is our viewpoint on the subject. I hope you glean some wisdom from it that will help you in making decisions for your family.

I just want to encourage you, too. You have many more children than I did so you have and will be on this journey of raising your children much longer than I. I know that you are weary and doubts come in like a flood at times---hang in there!! Stay connected with people who will pray for you and encourage you along the way regardless of the educational options you choose.

“And let us not grow weary while doing good, for in due season we shall reap if we do not lose heart.” Galatians 6:9

I would also appreciate your views on all this. The more we share and discuss, the better our understanding will be.

In His Grace,
Debbie
1455 Words

To view more 'News Items' Articles please 'Log In' and visit the 'Achives' page.

Thank You for Visiting Our Sponsors
HomeschoolingBooks.com

About Us    Approaches    Archives    Ask An Expert    Audios    Character Matters    Choosing Curriculum    Contact Us    FAQ    Getting Started   
High School    Home Page    Keeping Focus    Legal Information    Links    News Items    Product Reviews    Record Keeping    Search   
Sponsoring Sites    Support Groups    Teaching Tips    Terms To Know    Videos    What Is Homeschooling
.
Disclaimer                                         Right of Editorial Approval                                         Privacy Policy
.
Copyright 2008, 2009, 2010© — The copyright of this website and the material on this website (including without limitation but not limited to the text,
computer code, artwork, photographs, images, music, audio material, video material and audio-visual material on this website) is owned by HomeschoolingResourceCenter.org
[and its licensors] unless otherwise noted.
.
Contact the Webmaster